Cost basis · Funds and administrators · Oct 28, 2026 · 2 min read
FIFO, LIFO, HIFO and average cost: what changes for funds
How the lot method moves gains between years and between short and long term, and why book and tax often differ.
By ChainLedger editorial team · Crypto audit, tax and fund reporting · Last reviewed
Key takeaways
- The lot method doesn't change proceeds, but it can change gain, timing and holding period a lot.
- Average cost is common for NAV but generally not accepted for US federal tax on crypto.
- Book and tax figures must come from the same checked records, or they drift apart.
When a fund sells part of a position, the lot method decides which purchases count as sold. The proceeds are the same either way, but the cost, the gain and whether it's short or long term can change a lot.
The methods side by side
| Method | Which lots are sold first | Typical effect in a rising market |
|---|---|---|
| FIFO | Oldest | Larger gains, more of them long term |
| LIFO | Newest | Smaller gains, more short term |
| HIFO | Most expensive | Smallest gain now, larger later |
| Average cost | Every unit at the average price | Smooths gains, common for NAV |
A worked example
A fund bought three lots of 0.5 BTC, at $22,000, $72,000 and $54,000 per BTC, then sells 0.8 BTC for $84,000. Under FIFO the cost is the first lot plus part of the second, and much of the gain is long term. Under HIFO the $72,000 and $54,000 lots are used first, so the gain is far smaller and more of it is short term. Same sale, very different numbers.
Book versus tax
Many funds use average cost for book and NAV reporting, but average cost generally isn't an accepted method for US federal tax on crypto. Specific identification methods such as HIFO also need the lots to be identified at the time of sale. It's common to keep one method for investor reporting and another for tax.
Per-account tracking
Since January 1, 2025, US taxpayers are expected to track cost basis wallet by wallet and account by account. The method is applied inside each account, so the records need to know which account every lot sits in.
ChainLedger tracks lots per account and lets you run FIFO, LIFO, HIFO or average cost on the same checked records, so the tax forms and the investor reports never drift apart. You can switch methods and see exactly which lots move.
This guide is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules change and depend on the facts; confirm the treatment for any client with a qualified tax professional.
Related product page: Crypto tax software for CPA firms